PPSMI..ooopppsss ape tuh???

ASSALAMUALAIKUM DAN SELAMAT SEJAHTERA

kali ni post dila panjang..ia adalah kenyataan seseorang mengenai isu PPSMI..cite da lama dan dah basi pun..tapi dila nak rungkai balik apa itu PPSMI..mungkin ramai yang tak tahu dan mungkin tak ambil tahu pun..

sumber: tak ingat kat mana..dia ada terang apa itu PPSMI

Hi! I would like to share my idea about national education system in science and mathematics, as we all know PPSMI (Pengajaran & Pembelajaran Subjek Sains dan Matematik dalam Bahasa Inggeris) is abolished by our DPM/misnister of education Muhiyiddin and will not be available starting next year. From my opinion, PPSMI should not be abolish and should not be pose as an option! It should be reinstated as compulsory! Learning Science and mathematics in English has more pro than cons~Science subject is a subject that needs a lot of debating internationally for example, the use of gene therapy that alter the God's work, the code of ethnicity in blood transfusion and many more! How can u debate and participate in debate actively in international level when u can't speak scientific term in English fluently?! Early education to children is an important part of learning and what you teach them when they are young is most important! and sorry to say some teacher now don't deserve to be respected for them not able to think wisely and no enthusiasm in teaching pupils


i support dwibahasa.. penguasaan total.. i don't support the entire abolishment of PPSMI.. i can't say whether my statement will be bias or not coz i am raised to speak both language, but i was the 1st generation that experienced PPSMI (the guinea pig ^^).. based on what i heard from all my friends, they have benefited especially in the University level.. if u want to abolish PPSMI, plz abolish 90% of English oriented syllabus in the pre & University level so that all student be able to study at that level without wasting their entire 12 years of primary & secondary school learning in total BM. I am not against my own mother tongue, but i am speaking in term of educational interest. If the students can learn sci & math in both language, they have a choice, to be a better student that is good with both language or to be a student that can carry out with one language. i don't entirely blme teachers on teaching in English, but as we all are, if we be doctors, we wud try hard to b gud one, thus as teachers, a good teacher wud do all they can to master whatever knowledge needed of them. this is my opinion


 i really love this discussion. adakah AUKU 15(5)(a) yang dikatakan tidak sah telah membantu kita membuka ruang untuk perbahasan yang kritis sebegini. bagus foo yen. teruskan perbincangan isu semasa yang akan mematangkan pemikiran kita dan tidak hanya memikirkan masalah di dalam ruang lingkup kampus kita sahaja. bagi saya sendiri, PPSMI merupakan satu eksperimen yang ada yang menerima tempias baik dan ada yang menerima tempias kurang baik. bagi yang kurang baik, antara isunya adalah mengenai penguasaan bahasa inggeris yang masih lemah walaupun sc dan math diajar dalam bahasa inggeris. bermaksud disini, masalah sebenar bukan terletak pada subjek sc dan math dalam bahasa inggeris, tapi tiada penambahbaikan dalam subjek bahasa inggeris itu sendiri. jika mahu menghasilkan pelajar yang mahir bahasa inggeris, subjek bahasa inggeris yang perlu diperkasakan.bukan memaksa sc dan math dalam bahasa inggeris secara tiba2. guru math dan sc sendiri ada yang mengadu mereka tidak mampu menguasai dengan baik bahasa inggeris sehingga mereka hanya menggunakan bahasa melayu untuk bertutur,hanya istilah sc dan math sahaja dalam bahasa inggeris. ini juga mengelirukan pelajar. fokus pula kepada pelajar luar bandar, yang capaian guru mampu berbahasa inggeris dalam P&P adalah terhad.maka akhirnya masih lagi sama,pengajaran dalam bahasa melayu untuk memahamkan mereka. tapi tidak juga bersetuju dengan tindakan kerajaan memutuskan untuk terus menidakkan PPSMI kerana mampu memberikan ruang buat pelajar mengenal istilah-istilah sc dan math dalam bahasa inggeris. cuma, kejayaan sesebuah negara tidak terhad kepada penggunaan bahasa inggeris sahaja.jepun sentiasa menjadi contoh terdekat kita yang mana menjana pembangunan negara dengan bahasa mereka sendiri sebagai bahasa utama dalam semua bidang.orang eropah yang menggunakan bahasa inggeris yang banyak menterjemah karya daripada bahasa lain,contoh paling ketara adalah buku karya Ibnu Sina(bahasa Inggeris ialah Avicenna) yang diterjemah dari bahasa Arab ke bahasa Inggeris, Canon of Medicine (dalam bahasa Arabnya ialah “Al-Qanun fi al-Tibb”).belajar pelbagai bahasa itu amat bagus,tapi untuk memahami secara mendalam sesuatu perkara,perlukan penguasaan bahasa yang amat bagus.ini bukan hanya tentang sekadar menghafal istilah math dan sc.ini adalah mengenai memartabatkan ilmu. :)


LANGUAGE is not the ony aspect yang kita nilai. mcm Jepun, kenapa mereka boleh laksanakan pembelajaran entirely on their language? why Malaysia tidak? do we have to follow whatever other countries do in order to succeed (sorry ek, this is just questions yang kita perlu jawab).. Japan, although they have Nobel prize winners, they are embarassed when attend any scientific conferences because they cannot properly communicate in English.. like i say, nak memperkasakan educational system entirely on bahasa kita, then all educational level should di wajibkan in that language.Every reference book should be dwibahasa. then we can say utk menggunakan BM in all sci & maths subjects. Like Japan did starting from April 2011, Japan pun dah start wajibkan English. Singapore was ranked no 1 in their educational achievement. let's try compare with that country


japan, china & korea also a developing country before they bcome developed country..but they didn't use english....still can become great country...to be competitive, it must start from zero..:)..
i recommend those who disagree with the pemansuhan, please do research 1st...only then u will understand why people fight for PPSMI...logically u r right but in reality u r cruel...yes, early education for children is very important...and i also want to emphasize here, understanding is much2 important than debate,terms n so on...to've a good understanding you must 've a good basic...what will happen to those not good in english?..i was a tuition teacher b4 and it's very difficult to make them understand with english..need to change to bahasa & as a result they prefer to answer in bahasa rather in english..so, the main objective of PPSMI is failed.. our lecturers here also study in bahasa during their school-hood, and some of them study in bahasa at university level but they still can perform internationally...u r the one who can determine wether u r globally competitive or not, not PPSMI....:)


Actually from my point of opinion, sciences and mathematics in English is good if only the mediator (teacher & all those educator) is enthusiastic enough~No matter in what language, if the teacher has no enthusiasm in teaching, science and mathematics will be just as dull as nothing~nowadays, some of the teachers are not as dedicated as before especially the younger teachers. This is what I had gone through during my secondary school time, I had moved from rural school, to outskirt urban school and to urban school, I too had gone through Chinese vernacular schooling, National school, and missionary school~Along this path, I met some good dedicated teacher but mostly bad teachers who was always not entering class~to the extend sometime for a months straight, I dun get my chemistry teacher at all, and when some enter, they don't know how to explain either in BM or in BI (my physic teacher)~I just don't hope that the future students addressing in world stage with wrong scientific term~scientific term by itself is a totally different language~I prefer the government to improve the quality of teacher first before the government go and change any dasar pendidikan! Previously, the government had never give enough training to teacher and suddenly implement PPSMI, of cause, 200% PPSMI will fail if not 100%! That is y we see all statistic to fall rapidly! I believe during 1975, when Anwar Ibrahim changed English into Malay language in teaching, the statistic fell also~but in long term, who can tell which is better? There is no research on current long term achievement of PPSMI product and pre-PPSMI product~


seorang lelaki telah berjalan dengan anaknya, bersama seekor keldai. Ayahnya berkata, "Anak, kamu naik keldai, biar ayah yang pegang talinya.Ayah akan berjalan"

sampai ke satu tempat,orang2 melihat dan berkata sinis.
"teruk betul anak itu, ayah yang tua disuruh berjalan. cukup biadap"
maka si anak berkata.
"ayah, biar saya saja yang berjalan. Ayah pula duduk atas keldai ni"
lalu si anak berjalan memegang tali keldai, si ayah duduk di atasnya

sampai ke tempat yang lain, orang2 melihat dan berkata sinis.
"ada juga ayah sebegitu, kasihan melihat anaknya yang masih kanak2 berjalan"
maka kata si ayah, "naiklah anak, biar ayah saja yang berjalan"
jawab anak,"begini saja, kita dua2 naik keldai ni"

Lalu tiba di suatu tempat lain, orang2 melihat dengan senyum sinis
"tak berhati perut tuan keldai tu, kesian melihat keldai ditunggang dua orang"
kata si ayah, "anakku, kita berjalan saja"
jawab si anak, "ok,baiklah"

Lalu tiba di tempat yang lain, orang2 melihat dan berkata dengan kuat
"hahahaha, bodoh betul dua lelaki tu, seorang pun tak mahu menunggang keldai.bodoh macam keldai

p/s: dila tak nak komen kat sini lebih2 sebenarnya..tapi tujuan dila adalah nak kongsi apa itu PPSMI dan mungkin segelintir punya pendapat..pendapat anda pula bagaimana..dila tidak kata yang bahasa inggeris itu tidak penting tapi jika kita sendiri tidak menggunakan bahasa melayu, siapa lagi yang akan guna.dila sendiri pun bila belajar dalam bahasa inggeris tapi bila nak tukar sesetengah perkataan ke bahasa melayu dah tak tau da..blur habis kadang-kadang..huhuuuu..apa-apa pendapat setiap orang berbeza..jadi kita terima je yang mana baik..